February 5, 2012

FTC wants to Regulate Bloggers

images.jpg

Look out Mommy Bloggers and Reviewers, the government is coming to get you! According to the Washington Post (Article June 22, 2009) the Federal Trade Commission is reviewing guidelines it hopes to present later this summer that would regulate how bloggers disclose that they are receiving payments or freebies for their review. MomCentral (@momcentral) and IZEA (@IZEAinc) both of whom follow me on Twitter are mentioned in the article. I’ve met Stacy DeBroff very quickly after she spoke to IABC in San Francisco recently and put the following question to her via Twitter:

My question for @momcentral how do you stay transparent that you are tweeting/blogging for a paying client? #iabc09 ROI to SOI7:38 PM Jun 8th from Twittelator

I haven’t received an answer, yet. I’m sure Stacy or @MomCentral fields hundreds of direct tweets, so maybe they can’t answer them all, but it’s curious that the Washington Post singled them out over their practice of supplying coupons to Mommy bloggers so a certain product can be reviewed. IZEA on the other hand follows me, but has yet to reach out to me to offer any products or companies. But, it should be interesting how the FTC handles the slippery slope of trying to regulate the Internet.

Will bloggers go off-shore to accept payments for reviews? What about Twitter, much of the buzz on the microblogging site, is where do you put a disclaimer in the 140 characters you have to work with? I think the government should review the existing laws it has in place for retailers and the like. Rather than trying to chase down every Mom on a blog or band geek turned techno-blog reviewer, the U.S. Government should clamp down on the unscrupulous retailer trying to lure shoppers with “independent testimonials.” Code of ethics for bloggers are a good thing as well, and most bloggers who don’t disclaim they are receiving payment for their posts are soon uncovered by others who are trying to make blogging an trust-worthy news and information source. As for me, I have never taken payment for my thoughts, if I were, trust me, it would be disclosed.

What are your thoughts on this controversy?

Until next time, Tim

Other thoughts on the issue: Debbie WeilIdeas that SpreadWeblog Tools Collection

Motrin Feeling a Twittering Pain

Motrin is feeling the pain. The ad attached here was attacked online over the weekend, mainly from those of us on Twitter. Mothers complained it was offensive. What do you think?

Motrin Mom Babywearing Ad

The coverage from the mainline media, and the thousands of Tweets on Twitter made the company pull the ad from its website and issue an apology for upcoming print ads. The woman who sparked this controversy is L.A.-based blogger, freelance writer and mother, Jessica Gottlieb. On Saturday, she received a Twitter message asking her to check out the online Motrin video. Which she promptly did and started the firestorm, and then let the world know how much it offended her.

I don’t think the ad was that offensive, maybe the “trendy” part about wearing your baby and the obvious exaggeration about wearing “it on your side, your back” etc. was too much. But, people are entitled to their opinion, and they now have an instant venting mechanism. I guess this Motrin ad and McNeil Consumer Healthcare, will go down as a case history of companies trying to deal with a newly-empowered audience that can talk back to ads, almost instantly, even on a weekend. Search MotrinMoms on Twitter and see what I mean. One mom stayed up until 4AM to respond to the ad with a Youtube video.

On a somewhat related note, my friends Dan and Eileen just had their fifth child – a baby boy. Congratulations! I’ll have to ask them how they plan on carrying him?

Until next time, Tim